Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Has anyone ever tried microwave drilling?

yes, many times. as you would expect, it obviously doesn't work.

.

> Using gyrotrons to generate enough microwave power to cut and weld glass has supposedly been tried. The company that was doing it seems to have disappeared.

that's correct. they weren't able to cut two inches of well controlled non-porous dry material.

.

> You'd expect industrial applications first.

honestly, you wouldn't. it's technical nonsense. lasers are more efficient and easy to build.

the reason we use microwaves to cook is they pass through most material harmlessly, and mostly interact with the water.

which is kind of a dealbreaker here.

.

> So, drilling with some kind of energy beam looks worth the trouble.

no, it's really not. it's just science fiction bs.

if we want to save the planet, just build regular 1970s nuclear power, and quit it with the "i'll invent something new with less than ten years on the clock" stuff.



So what is the secret sauce here? Is it a scam? Are they bringing anything new to the table?

Their timeline is pretty tight with first rig in 2 years and commercial level first power plant in another 2. They should have demonstrated at least a couple of holes deeper than a few km by now you'd assume.


> So what is the secret sauce here?

There isn't one.

.

> Is it a scam?

It won't work.

I do not have the ability to tell if it's a scam. They might really believe it. A scam would require them to know they were wrong.

.

> Are they bringing anything new to the table?

No.

.

> Their timeline is pretty tight with first rig in 2 years and commercial level first power plant in another 2.

You can't even build a bog standard coal plant that fast.

.

> They should have demonstrated at least a couple of holes deeper than a few km by now you'd assume.

If you believed in them, yes, I'd agree.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: