Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

<disclaimer>I'm from Dyn.</disclaimer>

We're thrilled to see a new DNS performance monitoring tool in the public domain. It takes courage to release things like this to the world and open them up for critique, I applaud jimaek, the author, for doing just that.

As many have noted, the results are highly varied from many of the other reports we see today but more locations and tests are going to continue to improve accuracy.

The testing is synthetic, that is, it's run from within datacenters. I'd encourage anyone who can help provide/sponsor a VPS or resources to also do so. Providing consistent benchmarks against Authoritive Queries from know locations is great but the test network itself needs to expand to get truly meaningful comparisons between providers.

I'd hope to see real-user data also get added in the future, that is, testing on the end of home cable/broadband connections, these tests perform differently to synthetic tests but represent end-user experience more accurately.

It would also be great to see raw lookup performance between providers, exclusive of network latency.

For those interested in diving deeper into DNS performance, I'd also recommend reviewing Cloud Harmony's reports, the latest of which can be found here: https://cloudharmony.com/reports/state-of-the-cloud-dns-0315...



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: