Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>This is appealing to viewers who can follow what's going on and can feel a sense of accomplishment in learning a new trick. //

I don't really think that is true. Unless it's explained to them I don't see most viewers picking up on the subtly touches and strange hand/wrist holding, the body language mirroring, the use of the water bottle to distract, the placing and reinforcement of the suggestion?

Personally I think it appeals because it looks entirely like magic - "these are not the droids you're looking for" - to most observers the first time they watch. For me a great illusion is one where I can't see how it's done without at least watching a few times.

There are definitely some magicians using stooges, Dynamo is one who's pretty easy to spot, but if Brown is doing so then he's done really well to hide it as I'm sure the major news outlets would pay well for a person from one of his shows who could expose details to show it was a sham.

Brown's mix of NLP/hypnotism techniques with standard illusion and misdirection is what makes him so entertaining.



> I don't really think that is true. Unless it's explained to them I don't see most viewers picking up on the subtly touches and strange hand/wrist holding, the body language mirroring, the use of the water bottle to distract, the placing and reinforcement of the suggestion?

Yes, viewers can pick up on obvious things like handing someone a water bottle while telling them to give you their wallet and saying things like "You're happy to give that to me". It's only subtle enough for people to feel special in noticing it, but not so subtle for them not to notice it at all.

> Brown's mix of NLP/hypnotism techniques with standard illusion and misdirection is what makes him so entertaining.

What you brand as a demonstration of NLP/hypnotism I see as the psychology equivalent of "Divert auxiliary power from port nacelles to forward shields!"


There is probably a hell of a lot going on, the obvious stuff you do notice as well as very subtle stuff which all adds up. Certainly if you read up on NLP and hypnosis techniques, they talk about blood going to or away from the face depending on the state they are in. Patterns of eye movement corresponding to either remembering something or imagination depending on the direction.


> Brown's mix of NLP/hypnotism techniques

Brown has a pretty bad image of NLP so I'm not sure he would be happy that people say he is using NLP.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: