Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

He isn't comparing it to forced labor of some sort. He's comparing it to the nature of the social relationship between the users/service provides.


What? Ignoring the fact that I can't figure out what your second sentence means, obviously he's comparing it to forced labor. That's what we're talking about.


Trying to clarify what I mean, I'll probably give up after this as I'm on my 3rd day of very little sleep so perhaps I'm just incoherent.

My reading of his linked essay is as a discussion of the power dynamic between users and companies they rely on. This is compared with a romanticized version of feudalism. While the users are not compelled to actually use these services, once they enter into them they are at the mercy of the companies (feudal lords) to not take advantage of their much greater position of power (like his version of the early feudal era serfs).




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: