The only one who can lock me out of my relationship with e.g. HN is HN.
With passkeys:
Now I can be locked out by HN or by the passkey provider.
Sure I could use a local passkey provider, but the protocol provides a way for the site to enforce a whitelist of passkey providers, so it's not clear that would be an option. Particularly for businesses like banks which tend to adopt an approach of "if a security restriction is possible, it should be applied". Or even just the typical tech PM perspective of "we want to include logos for the log in with X, and I think more than 5 logos is ugly so let's just whitelist Lastpass, 1password, Google, Microsoft and apple and be done with it"
The only one who can lock me out of my relationship with e.g. HN is HN.
With passkeys:
Now I can be locked out by HN or by the passkey provider.
Sure I could use a local passkey provider, but the protocol provides a way for the site to enforce a whitelist of passkey providers, so it's not clear that would be an option. Particularly for businesses like banks which tend to adopt an approach of "if a security restriction is possible, it should be applied". Or even just the typical tech PM perspective of "we want to include logos for the log in with X, and I think more than 5 logos is ugly so let's just whitelist Lastpass, 1password, Google, Microsoft and apple and be done with it"