Unless we suppose those books describe how to implement a memory of sorts, and how to reason, etc. But then how sure are we it’s not conscious?
It's implied, since they enable someone who does not know Chinese to respond equally well to questions as someone with Chinese as a native language.
I'm not even sure what you are asking for, tbh, so any answer is fine.
Unless we suppose those books describe how to implement a memory of sorts, and how to reason, etc. But then how sure are we it’s not conscious?