No. What they are saying is best said with a quote from Battlestar Galactica:
> All of this has happened before, and all of this will happen again.
”It” here being the boom and inevitable bust of interop and open API access between products, vendors and so on. As a millenial, my flame of hope was lit during the API explosion of Web 2.0. If you’re older, your dreams were probably crushed already by something earlier. If you’re younger, and you’re genuinely excited about MCP for the potential explosion in interop, hit me up for a bulk discount on napkins.
And then, there are "architecture astronaut"s dreaming of an entire internet of MCP speaking devices - an "internet of agents" if you will. That is now requiring a separate DNS, SMTP, BGP etc. for that internet.
I think battlestar Galactica must be quoting one of the Eddas. I've only read if it from Borges in Spanish, but Conner the same meaning: "Estas cosas han pasado. Estas cosas también pasarán."
I'm older and would like a discount please. The "this time it's different" energy is because assuming a human can interact with the system, and that vision models can drive a gui, who cares if there's an actual API, just have the AI interact with the system as if it was coming in as a human.
What's the point of stating the obvious if the obvious won't change anything? Things evolve. Winners win and losers lose. Change is constant. And? Does that somehow mean there's nothing to see here and we should move on?
No, things can change but we programmers tend to see everything as a technical problem, and assume that if only we can find a good technical solution we can fix it. But the problem isn’t technical – the APIs were shut down because consumer tech is governed by ads, which are not part of APIs (or would be trivial to remove). You have surely noticed that APIs are alive and well in enterprise, why? Because they have customers who pay money, and API access does not generally break their revenue stream (although even there some are skittish). As mere ”users” our economic function in consumer tech is to provide data and impressions to advertisers. Thy shall not bypass their sidebar, where the ads must be seen.
Nowadays the shutdown is not just of APIs but even anti-scraping, login walls, paywalls, fingerprinting, and so on and so forth. It’s a much more adversarial landscape today than during Web 2.0. When they threw copyright in the trash with the fair use loophole for AI, that obviously causes even more content lockdown panic. And in the midst of this giant data Mexican standoff, people are gonna take down their guns and see the light because of a new meta—API protocol?
> All of this has happened before, and all of this will happen again.
”It” here being the boom and inevitable bust of interop and open API access between products, vendors and so on. As a millenial, my flame of hope was lit during the API explosion of Web 2.0. If you’re older, your dreams were probably crushed already by something earlier. If you’re younger, and you’re genuinely excited about MCP for the potential explosion in interop, hit me up for a bulk discount on napkins.