Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> is Chinese as evidenced by their misspelling of English words

Ad hominem and wrong logic. Evidenced by your correct English spelling so you must be white English people?

> distinct beliefs

Like what? The belief was exactly repeated by Chinese mythology, the Di's of 5 Color, the 10 suns, the birdie thing. All Chinese rulers inherited the "Di" title from Shu. Yellow Emperor had a Shu wife, his son had a Shu wife, I'd argue it's been Shu all along.

> bronze casting ... which China did not

Please do more research. Some of the major bronze casting set were replicas found in other parts of Yangtze river

> because they were illiterate

> Confucian parent

funny you mentioned Confucian. Did you know (one of) Confucius's teacher came from Shu? During Zhou dynasty, several early "teacher of the king", including (quite possibly) the incredible Jiang Ziya "Esteemed Father", were from the Shu & Qiang clans, to be specific, Jiang and Qiang are basically the same character on bronze inscriptions, literally meaning the shepherd people, which lives in western China.

> based upon modern Chinese nationalism

Hey bro I thought you were calling Han vs non-Han bullshit? Why change the subject to "Chinese"? Are you suggesting Han == China or something? Mind you, Han is a nationalism invention during the 1910s.

Overall I think "China/Chinese" is a messed up umbrella term, so sorry I am more like Basuria/Shu-ism.

If you want to show off your online racial supremacy you have won, but if you want to discuss about some East Asian history or archaeological findings, I don't like your arrogance and bigotry.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: