Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> corporate policies, material interests, and countless other drivers of corporate decisionmaking

And those policies came from...?

And those material interests relate to...?

...the ether? Jesus Christ? The "Invisible Hand"? The void?

Those policies were written by people at the direction of people to be given to people to do because some people are interested in achieving that goal.



> Those policies were written by people at the direction of people to be given to people to do because some people are interested in achieving that goal.

And those policies continue to be in effect long after any of their authors or beneficiaries have left or otherwise ceased to be authors or beneficiaries - as highlighted in the part of my comment immediately following that which you quoted.

People being involved at one point says nothing about their continued involvement or about the eventual autonomy of the thing with which they were once involved - just like how any person's decisionmaking is independent from that of one's constituent cells, and from one's parents and their constituent cells. The interests of the creation can and do diverge from the interests of the creators.


Companies inherit quasi-cognitive abilities not merely from the people they make up, but the structures of their interactions, particularly power structures. This creates something emergent that wasn't there before.

Your argument is like saying "we've already solved biology -- it's physics all the way down!" Except, it's not. The information-processing and entropy-generating capacities of biological organisms surpasses those that would be expected from a purely physical perspective.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: