Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The first step would be to stop calling them Depositors. They are not and were never Depositors. That is what you have deposit boxes for...You do not have money at the Bank. You loaned money to the Bank. That is why they pay you interest on it...


For the downvoters... "International Monetary Fund - What Is a Bank?" - https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/fandd/2012/03/basics.ht...

".... Banks are intermediaries between depositors (who lend money to the bank) and borrowers (to whom the bank lends money)..."


Amazing the IMF has a misconception of how banks work in their “basics” explanation!

From the Bank of England: “[…] Where the stock of bank deposits comes from is often misunderstood. One common misconception is that banks act simply as intermediaries, lending out the deposits that savers place with them.”

1. https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/-/media/boe/files/quarterly-...


No. The Bank of England has it wrong...

"...Transactions on deposit accounts are recorded in a bank's books, and the resulting balance is recorded as a liability of the bank and represents an amount owed by the bank to the customer..."

"Deposit account" - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deposit_account

"Does The Money In Your Bank Account Really Belong To You?" - https://www.sgrlaw.com/does-the-money-in-your-bank-account-r....

"...At the moment of deposit, the funds become the property of the depository bank...Thus, as a depositor, you are in essence a creditor of the bank. Once the bank accepts your deposit, it agrees to refund the same amount, or any part thereof, on demand..."


Your citation for why they aren't depositors refers to them as depositors. I'm confused.


And your confusion is completely normal. An insidious action expressly used by the interested, in manipulating language for it's purposes. It has already been nicely addressed by Weinberg in his books.

That is why every dry desert urban development in the middle of nowhere, with hardly any water for hundreds of miles, is called... Watery Creek...That is why employees are sometimes called business partners, that is why private investments funds are in some countries called pensions, and finally the reason why creditors at banks are called depositors. To delude you into making you believe, you are or have more, than what you really are, or might have.

"The Secrets of Consulting" - https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/secrets-consulting-guide-givi...


Sounds like this commenter is not just arguing that language is being used incorrectly in this situation, but that the standard language and definitions are themselves propaganda terms.

(Usually people are a little clearer about their intent to argue that.)


Yes that is what I am saying. And agree, could have expressed it in a more clear way.


For most of the past decade, banks haven't been paying interest on deposits, because rates were so low.


The value of the interest is not relevant to the truthiness of the concept. And zero is still a number, although some mathematicians might not agree...


Isn't that literally the definition of a bank depositor?


Yes in the world of Finance, but the word has a different meaning, in the mind of said Depositors...The word is used by Government and Banks, as a misdirection into a false sense of security.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: