Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I disagree with two of your three points:

(paraphrasing, fairly I hope)

> Objective-C is too much work/too low-level for your app/required because the hardware is limited.

Disagree. I wouldn't be disappointed to see solid Cocoa bindings in another approved language, but any programmer can learn C, and should. ObjC is a superset of C, and Cocoa is a beautifully consistent framework. The brackets might take a day or two to get used to, but they pretty much disappear after that. The much talked-about memory management model is not nearly as daunting as bloggers make it sound.

> Designing hugely complex monolithic apps is difficult on the iPhone.

Well, OK. I don't disagree with that entirely. But design is always serious work, information architecture is an art and science, especially for highly complex applications. That said, your app is not Photoshop and a good designer can solve your problems. Photoshop on an iPhone would be Difficult. So would XCode.

> App store discoverability is poor, marketing around launches is unpredictable, betas and limited releases are complicated or unworkable, audience feedback is a big problem.

Agreed 100%...! :)

Good luck with your dev!



Photoshop is modular, not monolithic.

Designing a large monolithic anything is insanely hard. It's often best to design around it.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: