Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> because we wouldn't want any place for the homeless to feel human either

I'm sorry, that is nonsense. Who is "we" anyway? Voters? Government? The rich and famous? C'mon.

Nobody cares about who uses a bathroom. The issue is how it is used and cared for.

Public bathrooms, regardless of the venue, tend to suffer from the tragedy of the commons [0] effect. Most people use them as they would their own bathroom at home. All you need is a very small percentage who just don't care, who are absolute pigs, to ruin them for everyone. If you have ever gone to a public restroom at a Los Angeles beach you know exactly what I am talking about. They are nothing less than disgusting and sometimes revolting. And this is so due to a small percentage of animals (1%? Who knows?) who have no concept of social responsibility and consideration towards others.

My guess is you are not aware of what happened this year at schools all over the US [1] (and maybe elsewhere). This, again, was at the hands of a very small number of kids who, for who-knows-what-reason decide it is OK to behave like animals. At our kids school a handful (3 to 5?) actually got arrested. The school had to close all bathrooms except for two. Students had to ask for permission to go and could only go one at a time. They had to post a person outside each bathroom to go inspect it after a student got done. The animals caused tens of thousands of dollars in damages and the inconvenience to well-behaved kids cannot be measured.

And then there's a sense of scale. If you own a small restaurant, you can't have 300 people come in just to use the bathroom. You are not a bathroom facility. These things cost money and upkeep and, yes, they need to be clean and available for customers. At the limit you'd have to hire multiple staff just to clean and maintain the bathrooms --because they will get trashed.

As is always the case, reality isn't driven by a single convenient variable. One has to consider the multiple (tens, hundreds...) of drivers behind any effect. It isn't single-cause -> effect. It's often incomprehensibly-complex-multivariate-problem -> effect.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons

[1] https://www.google.com/search?q=kids+trashing+school+bathroo...



I think at some point public-private bathrooms (private owned/maintained bathrooms for public use) will employ ML/CV to identify vandals.

I suspect a camera that either operates outside visible light (or has a filter that operates as such), or that is limited wrt what information it is able to stream out (i.e. it can run ML/CV on raw video, but can only communicate the results rather than any part of the video feed).

Could also be useful in identifying e.g. people who pass out in a toilet cubicle.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: