Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> when a company has a monopoly on a network it stops functioning as a company and basically becomes a government.

That is very aptly put. To go on a bit of a tangent, I would go even further and say that companies are always a form of government, even without a monopoly, but the addition of a monopoly just extends the power and reach of such individual government.

In the modern capitalist systems, the collective of all companies together are the branch of govern that decide what will be produced and where-and-how people are going to work, all that under the checks and balances of the free-market and the official branches government. That is, an individual company is a form of tiny local government (not local in geography, but in scope) with the mandate to govern some aspects of the life of their employees (what they will be doing for 40h a weak), and the production of their particular products, being that mandate can be removed and transferred to other company by the free market.

Now, I know that this metaphor I described is not a 100% perfect fit, if stretched to the extremes it will arrive at absurd corners where companies are nothing like governments. But then, no metaphor is perfect, not even the metaphor officially supported by the USA Judiciary branch, that "companies are people". They are only useful, and only fit in small contexts, and as such I believe "companies are government" is a very useful one and should be part of the discourse.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: