Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

"Virus Scanner" is optional, many ways to disable it, you won't be arrested if you are infected, and government doesn't get to decide what virus is.

Apple scanning is NOT optional, if they have false match or mess up you will be charged/investigated for one of THE most hated crimes in human history, even if you win the case the damage will be irreparable.

You lost your mind if you think governments are not going to setup their own CSAM database hashes with their own "manual review" centers. Apple will not be able to jack shit on what each country considers CSAM.



It is optional to use iCloud Photos. There's no indication you get arrested if they find something, it isn't reported directly to FBI. Apple will just disable your account, and there is an appeals process to restore it if they made a mistake.

There's more nuance here beyond the clickbait headlines.


> There's no indication you get arrested if they find something

Yes, you are.

> it isn't reported directly to FBI

NCMEC is the FBI.

>Apple will just disable your account, and there is an appeals process to restore it if they made a mistake.

Good luck appealing from your jail cell or with confiscated devices

>There's more nuance here beyond the clickbait headlines.

Please stop spreading false information


> Apple will just disable your account

That's the only thing they are going to do? That can't be right. What's the point, then?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: