Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Correct, it has no impact on the internals of Git, which was my point. Git's internals are used by both the kernel development workflow and the GitHub-style workflow, and Linus designed it well.

The conversation is about the user experience of using Git - its CLI design, etc. It is entirely about "merely" what commands are being used. TFA is about new Git commands, not about any changed internals. Or, in the case of Sourcetree, it's about not using any of "Linus's" interface to Git (which, again, wasn't written by Linus) but interacting with the same Git internals.



I think the conversation is about whether or not the Sourcetree interface to git can be useful when carrying out tasks that involve, for example, filtering the reflog.

If you have never done this before, and have only ever used git via the ST interface, switching to the CLI to get this done is going to be quite a shock. Maybe that's OK because realistically such tasks should be rare. But sometimes they are a critical task in development, and finding that the entire dev team is completely intimidated by it can be an issue.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: