Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

[flagged]


But it isn't abolished in all states, and India is the largest exporter of beef. Beef politics is new and a recent BJP/Modi/Adityanath invention.

It is the same tactics the British used to divide the country, and simply used as a tool to target Muslims.

The fact is that Hindus eat beef and there is no religious proscription against it, that is the whole point of "Hinduism being a way of life".

Secondly - old cows are not a resource, and farmers do not care about them. You cannot support their population without making cows useless to farmers. So cows get slaughtered.

The efforts made to politicize this has lead to herds of cows destroying farmers and farm land. Now that the attention of the population is away from cows, I bet farmers and politicians are busy shipping cows to be butchered once again.

Its pretty amazing that no one wonders who is selling these cows to be killed, it only becomes an issue when muslims eat meat.


> criticising the central government

Conveniently leaving the truth that those state government which banned beef is same as central government (ruling central government party). People killed on suspicion of storing beef in home refrigerator is also perpetrated by central government party and its members (this is the reason no one got punished or prosecuted for mob killing). Central government has wide powers to initiate investigations and punish local officials as they have constantly done to muzzle political opponents in every state where they are not in power.

> marriage act

There is a reason it’s called Hindu marriage act and it’s very patriarchal with lots of inconsistencies. Not just this, there are many laws in India which needs repeal or reform like laws on sedition’s which are conveniently used by current government to put people in jail without trial trampling basic human rights. For higher courts it’s important to judge what a comedian can say or not say and habeas corpus cases are just kept pending. A minister of central government is outraged and any court takes up the case with utmost urgency, and person languish in jails for years waiting for their habeas corpus plea pending hearing.

> Muslim reforms

Let that community decide what reforms they want, don’t impose your will on them.

May be follow a bit of Buddhism to do self introspection and all will be evident.


Nationalistic and religious flamewar will get you banned here. You did that repeatedly in this thread. Please don't post any more like this to HN, regardless of which side you're fighting for or how right you feel it is.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html


>>Beef consumption has been forbidden in most Indian states since independence and supported by all political parties.

Only 'Productive Cow(milk yielding)' slaughter was forbidden until recently. Karnataka(Ruled by same party as the center) recently banned all bovine slaughter. Farmers now say they will happily pass on the expenses to take care of unproductive cattle(calves, bulls and older bovines) to consumers in the form of higher priced milk.

Regarding the remaining thing. As a Married Indian muslim who has registered their marriage. All Indian muslims go under special marriage act whose provisions are way way more stricter than the Hindu marriage act. They even send out your application to the local mosques in Bangalore to check if this is a genuine alliance or if the couples have eloped and parents have objections to file. The time given is 45 days. All the best registering a marriage between a Muslim and Hindus.

>>It may forbid triple talaq but other provisions like custody and alimony still apply.

Literally negligible follow triple talaq in Muslim community. In my entire biological and parents biological existence and our entire network of friends and family we don't of a single case of divorce happening this way.

Things like 498a and DV laws apply to all Indian citizens as they are criminal laws.

The reason why people protested against 3T is because even a random stranger could accuse a Muslim man of 3T and the criminal proceedings begin, with arrest and imprisonment of the Muslim man. tl;dr a law created to reign in strong men who wouldn't bow to your political/religious harassment.

>>Protests, crazy ones just like for the CAA.

It's quite a telling about you when you say refusal to walk into concentration camps as crazy.


And the reason all this happens is because a uniform civil code is unpalatable to muslims. We would be in a better place if we didn't have polygamy and good divorce, custody, alimony laws instead of religious laws.


What does cow slaughter laws have to do with laws governing marriage


Both are religious in nature




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: