Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

For whoever voted me down:

  1. The joke is old and I assumed that most of us have heard it before
  2a. What he said really didn't comment on the article
  2b. Therefore, I felt the comment didn't add anything
  2c. I would, however, automatically expect to see such a comment on Reddit
  3. The fact that it's being voted up (5 at this point) disappointed me
  4. I voted him down. People always complain when they are voted down without explanation 
  5. I intended my previous comment to explain why I voted him down
That's all. I could make the leap and say that the quality of comments here is going down, but that might be going too far for everyone's tastes.


If everyone explained their downvote in comments, how crappy do you think this site would be? Please don't.


I could make the leap and say that the quality of comments here is going down, but that might be going too far for everyone's tastes.

So set a good example and don't reply to downmods with 7 reasons why your comment shouldn't have been downmodded. Even good comments get downmodded from time to time; deal with it.


Voting you down for insufficient explanation, are 5 bullet points really all you can manage when explaining something of this magnitude?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: