Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Really the only issue I have with carplay is

1. That I can't tell siri to play things on spotify, etc, although apparently siri support for spotify is coming. I'm on the iOS 13.1 beta but it's still not there

2. Carplay limits the listing of bands/albums/songs in the menu. I get that they don't want me visually scrolling through hundreds of albums while I'm driving, but since there's no carplay search, and I can't (yet) control spotify with siri, this means to play the music I want I have to pick up my phone and select my music from there. Much less safe than if they just listed all my music on the screen.

They list far more albums when the car is at a stop, but it's still not all of it. Scrolling through my artists gets me to about G before it stops listing.

Siri support for spotify really can't come soon enough for me.



I think Spotify needs to implement Siri support so I’m not surprised that it doesn’t work on the beta. I’m also excited for this integration because I loathe Apple Music. Spotify is so much better. It’s annoying that Spotify doesn’t work as wel natively. If Apple Music was just a Spotify clone, I’d happily switch to them just for the first party support, but they insist on making it different. Spotify’s interface and music organization is just so much better.


Yeah, after the latest beta release if I ask siri to play on spotify she says "Spotify hasn't set up playing from siri yet" or something along those lines. I'm gonna be a happy camper when it starts working.


The truncated lists are imposed by the car manufacturer, not Apple. I agree it's very annoying.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20833791


Apple provide the API, so this is just the car manufacturer doing "the right thing".

I think the wording may some "certain cars" enforce it because after-market head units may not be connected up to the speedometer and therefore have no way of including this information.


We have a Suzuki that’s supposed to disable most of the touch screen controls when driving (including the TV/DVD and changing any navigation settings aside from zoom), but the used car dealer we bought it from informed us that he had already disconnected that sensor as a routine service to us...


I assume the car companies asked for this functionality. Mazda's UI locks out a bunch of functionality when the car is in motion.


This whole time I thought 2 was just a terrible bug. It was one of the reasons I switched to android.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: