Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I've been doing a large amount of video production that is published to Facebook for the last few years. Mostly live, some post / uploaded work. But the live productions stats the morning after an event are extremely suspect. It seems like the numbers astronomically inflated.


So who do you suspect is the bad actor and what is their motivation?


Facebook. More money.


I don’t follow. How would FB profit from showing you an inflated number of plays? Are you paying them for plays?


When you sit in meetings and hear the social media and sales people spit their numbers, and it defies all forms reality...

Well, they look good to the company and the bosses eat up the voodoo science they are preaching.

I've yet to ever see true ROI or accurate numbers of any kind coming out of Facebook or Instagram for content or marketing campaigns. Instagram is mostly a bot problem. Facebook has loose impression and view numbers. YouTube hasn't ever been a red flag in my experience, but I've never been involved with any ad work there, just content.


Inflated efficacy of Facebook as a platform.


Many of the numbers I've seen are more in line with impressions. The app loading and being somewhere in a timeline dramatically inflates their numbers. In reality, I know a lot of people who see little to no gain from Facebook as a platform at this point. Especially for small business.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: