Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

So I've tried using several bluetooth headphones before Airpods were around. They all sucked. Things like audio stuttering while inches away from the transmitter and short battery life is what made them suck. I gave up on bluetooth headphones for good; I hated them. Oh and the convenience of wireless wasn't even that important to me (or so I thought).

Now I have a pair of airpods and I love them. The improvement is marginal, but it's an improvement that touches many aspects of my life (commuting, cooking, sleeping, working). I love, love, love them.

> Does anyone truly believe they removed the headphone jack for any reason other than to sell more dongles and more wireless headphones?

I think Apple believes that wireless headphones are the future and they decided to prove that it can be done right. IMO they succeeded with airpods.

Removing the headphone jack was a forcing function. It's only an issue if you don't buy into the Apple ecosystem. Obviously that's a risk, but it's a risk that Apple has taken before.

Assuming it's some kind of cockameme plan to sell more dongles doesn't really fit the profile of Apple as a company, IMO.



I used a 15gbp bluetooth headphone 6 years ago without any problems on both linux and android; battery life was fine, even sound quality was acceptable. Colleagues have been using Bose ones for years. Apple didn't fix anything.


I mostly agree, but wasn’t making them independent from each other (ie no cord between the two sides) an innovation?


Innovation? Yes. Fix? No. Needed? Debatable.

Ditching the only analogue sound connector was without question a bad idea though.


Bluetooth headphones are only really good since Bluetooth 4 and its Low Energy standard. Everything before used too much power and connections were to fragile, as you noticed.

If you tried other Bluetooth headphones than the Airpods now, you would also notice the better battery life. My work headphones (over-ear) only need to be charged on the weekend after over 40h of use and they are very light, too.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: