Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It's very true that in terms of hotel booking many consumers still see the big OTAs as the "bargain" sites and are often surprised to find that you can usually get an equal or better rate by booking directly with a hotel chain itself.

The company I work for, roomkey.com, was founded by six of the largest hotel chains to address this problem and bring more direct bookings back to the chains. The OTA duopoly of Expedia and Priceline have many of the hotel chains over a barrel with very aggressive contract terms that do not allow the hotel chain to advertise a lower direct rate than those they supply to the OTAs. And added to this, the OTAs take a pretty eye-watering commission.

However, most of the big chains are able to provide a lower rate to their own loyalty members. Room Key is unique in that we can access and aggregate these lower rates into a one-search solution. But, we are a tiny voice and competing with annual online marketing budgets of over a billion dollars each for the big two OTAs. Our job is a very hard one.

I'm glad articles like this are starting to paint a truer picture for the consumer. It really does make sense to book direct almost every time. It's easier to cancel/modify. You are the customer of the hotel, not a third party. You get loyalty benefits. And more of your money goes to those who take on the overhead of your stay and ensure the quality of your experience.

The OTAs used to be both cheap and convenient. Now they can only really lay claim to convenience through aggregation, and we at roomkey.com are trying to change that too.



Agoda often offers discounts to hotels you've viewed if you're browsing around and I always get the hotel cheaper than what's on offer at the hotel directly. For example the hotel I'm currently staying at in Taiwan cost 2500 NT, booking directly with the hotel is actually 4100 NT...

I don't understand how this is possible but this is how it seems to me.

I don't use things like flight scanner because booking directly with the airline is always cheaper from experience.


Actually. Google flights usually has prices that match the airline. I sometimes use that to compare. Then go to the airline site directly to do the booking.


I haven't seen Google offer booking.


Flights.Google.com doesn't offer bookings but it's good for comparing.


It looks like roomkey.com doesn't seem to have any mobile apps, which makes it hard to say that it's more convenient to use when traveling than an aggregator that does have an app.

It's interesting to hear about your site though, perhaps I'll try it out next time I'm traveling.


Just so you know, your site is completely broken on mobile when users use Firefox Focus.


We're aware of the issues - and we're working on a much improved mobile presence. Coming soon. Thanks for the feedback.


Oddly enough, I just tried to book an ihg hotel through priceline, and priceline said it was sold out. ihg was happy to give me the reservation directly though.


If you ever visit Ottawa, you're far better off booking through an aggregator. Most hotels have a very, very strict cancellation policy.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: