Looks on the surface remarkably similar. Yeah, no horses, less pedestrians (though not by all that much), public transport seems the same, about as many people on bikes and many more cars. But the basic building blocks didn’t change by much.
Everything is much tighter regulated, though, (pretty much a necessity when enough cars are involved) and as a consequence everything looks a lot less chaotic.
I used to ride my bike to work on Market Street, and to me this video seems unusually serene. If it was filmed during rush hour, which I don't think this was, your conclusion about it being less chaotic might be different...or maybe things just seem much more intense from a bicycle perspective.
I used to drive a cab in the city a couple years ago and the bikers situation on Market street during rush hour was pretty chaotic from that perspective as well :P
The street is Euclid Ave. which borders the central U.C. Berkeley campus to the north.
Do be sure and note (a) the same generally languid approach to street travel; (b) the role of the fine gentlewoman in breaking up a dispute before it descends to far into fisticuffs. I think that the guy walking on the tracks might be black and so I suspect there is also a racial element to these snapshots of history, but I'm not sure. I'm also not so sure that the confrontation we see in the video wasn't staged - it looks like it could have been but it's hard to tell.
Did it strike anyone else that in all likelihood, every single person in the video is dead now, even the kids? I didn't even know they had video in 1906...
I got about half way through and then had the amusing thought, "Wow. These people would flip out if they saw it now." and the became depressed since they're all dead, heh :/
The blog says the street seems wider in the 1908 film. I think that's a combination of a lack of street trees and curbs, and shorter buildings in the background.
I wonder why the car doesn't stop for passengers. You can see several waiting. One even waves at the driver. My thought is that either the car was stopping and the video was edited, or it was a special run for the benefit of the camera.
A few more observations:
* While there are many fewer pedestrians in the 2005 video, there are more bicycles. And the bicycles actually have adults on them (not sure about the guy in the cape though).
* The streetcar seems to move much faster in 2005, covering considerably more ground in less time.
* While 2005 looks much more orderly, automobiles are still erratically darting out in front of the streetcar. Some things don't change I guess..
Wow and it is a music video for Air...double bonus! There is an incredibly cool map store in San Francisco, and as you would expect, the proprietor is very friendly. It is called Schein and Schein (http://www.scheinandschein.com/ the website doesn't do it justice) and they have some beautiful old maps and photobooks, with a large portion of the collection devoted to SF and California history.
It's strange to imagine a time when "oh, look, a motorcar!" might be uttered with the same sense of technological novelty as "oh, look, an iPad!" today.
The blogger notes that Market Street seemed wider than it does today. I disagree; it really looks about the same. Keep in mind that the sidewalk is much larger now than it appears to be in 1906.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vqcz_tllnwM
I'm really glad someone did the 100 year anniversary version.
2105 will be all nanorobots or something.