Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | culturthrowaway's commentslogin

This is a splash of cold water if you're familiar with who Ben Collins is.

This will not not be a return to The Onion you fondly remember. Most likely it will be a continuation in the same direction it's been going.


OK, I’ll bite: why?

I don’t know who Ben Collins is and at a first read of his bio I’m not really sure who would. My first instinct is that this is one of those terminally online things, like how I kept reading references to “Taylor Lorenz” as if she were the devil incarnate and when I finally looked into it she was just another pretty boring journalist.


Since you asked, a genuine answer. I suspect it's because Ben Collins is a veteran of the left-wing "disinformation" beat, most recently for MSNBC until he lost that gig -- so the admittedly cryptic parent comment is positing that as a seasoned culture warrior, Collins will likely apply The Onion as a tool in the culture war.

The Onion's comedic point-of-view used to be less predictable, but as the culture war as progressed, so too has The Onion's voice, and it's a more reliable voice for the left these days. If you rue that trend, for whatever reason, Collins provides little reason to imagine things will change.


I was genuinely excited to see him be the new boss. He's incredibly smart and incisive and really understands internet culture.


I'm not familiar enough with either him or culture war dynamics to know what you mean by this.


On the other hand he does have experience in the field.


Ben Collins, the guy who got suspended from MSNBC for criticizing Elon Musk too hard? Upset Nate Silver because he criticized him too hard? Upset Matt Taibbi for making fun of him for doing PR work for a billionaire? I think he’s perfect for the job honestly.


If _MSNBC_ thinks he’s too overtly partisan and not up to journalistic standards, I’d say Collins fails to clear the absolute lowest bar in news media ethics.


Boy do I have to warn you about The Onion’s content then.

Also if you think being partisan is the lowest bar instead of “report the truth” or “be accurate and fair” then that tells me enough already about your values.


The very first thing to do when clicking through to an article about SNL is obviously to ctrl-f G-I-L-L... 0 results. Okay, probably not going to bother, it looks pretty long.

Then I notice the author. Crazy lol.


To make it clear to those unfamiliar, Seth Simons initiated the 'cancellation' of Shane Gillis and can be seen, for that reason, as a major agitator for 'cancel culture'.


The Gilly character?


A constant worldview-pervading awareness of Jewishness as an ethnicity is only really widespread in 4 groups of people: particularly ethnic-chauvinist Jews, the hardest-core antisemites, and their victims.

Wishing for more Jews to become much more aware of their ethnicity would be one of those monkey's paw wishes.


Out of interest, are there any other groups where you believe that it would be dangerous for members of that group to be "aware of their ethnicity"? Or is it only Jews?


This is a description, not a prescription. Also do note the adjectives.

I'd say it is universal for any group, but given particular circumstances in the actual state of the world its salience varies widely.


RIP Terry


The cultural engineers need to be careful, people might start wondering why the overlays are blank in Europe.


Refraining from packing the court is one of the very last truces still in place just barely holding the country together by a thread.

I truly wonder what you suppose the marginal odds are that you or someone you love is killed in an event that your proposed action would prevent, vs the marginal odds that you or someone you love is killed as a somewhere-down-the-line butterfly effect of your trying to take that action?


North Korean leader Kim Jong Un has been granted the title of marshal, state media reported Wednesday, cementing his status as the authoritarian nation's top military official as he makes key changes to the million-man force.

The decision to award Kim, who already serves as supreme commander of the Korean People's Army, was made Tuesday by the nation's top military, government and political officials, state media said in a special bulletin.

The formal move to bestow the title of marshal to Kim comes seven months into his rule and follows several days of reshuffling at the highest levels of the military.


https://old.reddit.com/search?q=youtube+shadowban

https://old.reddit.com/search?q=youtube+ban

Far from exhaustive, I'm sure this happens quietly to many more small creators who've crossed the wrong invisible line, asked the wrong good-faith question, or gotten too close to a forbidden subject even while covering something else entirely.

But it should be clear even from what little's made it to be documented that what YouTube will suppress has already quietly dipped pretty deep into your personal overton window, if you ever even pretended to care about real free expression.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: